American Tonneau Vs Gator

American Tonneau Vs Gator: Which is Better?

A tonneau cover is a perfect accessory for your truck. It protects the tonneau and helps you keep the truck bed clean while also adding space to carry items.

If someone is genuinely concerned about the debate of American tonneau cover vs Gator, then he/she might have an interest in this article.

The main differences that we will highlight today are design, construction material, installation, security, and price. You will also find a product suggestion section where we have short-listed some of the top-performing tonneaus that might end your quest for a perfect truck cover.

Quick comparison Table

Key FactorsAmerican Tonneau CoverGator Tonneau Cover
DesignLow ProfileLow Profile
Construction materialVinyl, Aluminum frame and support bowsheavy-duty vinyl, aluminum framework and bows, and water-resistant foam rubber seals
Installation5 to 10-minute install time w/ no tools neededEasy
SecuritySimple latching systemTailgate Lock
Types Availablesoft tri-folding, hard tri-folding, soft rollingRoll up, folding and retractable
PriceBetween $239 to $499Between $150 to $1350

American Tonneau cover

For many years, the American tonneau company has been famous for its soft tri-folding and hard tri-folding truck bed covers. Depending on the brand and model, these covers are secured over the area and sealed with Velcro, clips, zippers, or other mechanisms.

American tonneau covers are a popular choice for protecting cargo in the bed of a truck or at times when you do not want your items in view behind the trunk. American tonneau covers vary according to style and design, but they all have a general design that protects the car from weather elements and provides security from theft.


  • Easy to operate
  • Easy to install – no assembly required
  • Strong and lightweight structure
  • Heavy duty hinges and seals keep the elements out
  • Vinyl Grain finishing


  • Locking mechanism can be improved

Gator Tonneau Cover

Gator tonneau covers are built with a low-profile design, making it seem like there is no cover when installed correctly on your truck’s bed! They have been making tonneaus since 1967 and doing the business with experience generation after generation.

These covers are made out of the toughest, most durable material to ensure that they last as long as possible. You will find these covers come in many different styles and colors, so you can be sure to find one that suits your style!

Gator tonneau covers also have special features such as an extra lock hole, additional latch holes, or an anti-theft device. Gator even uses UV-resistant material where applicable.


  • Modern locking mechanism
  • Low profile design
  • Hassle-free installation
  • Lightweight
  • Affordable price


  • The rear clamp screw may be improved (For some models)
American Tonneau Vs Gator

Comparison Between American and Gator tonneau cover

It’s a good idea to weigh out your options before deciding. So, let’s see how the two types of covers rack up against each other.


In terms of design, the American and Gator tonno cover manufacturers are tough compotators. Both of them produce low-profile and modern truck bed covers with easy-to-operate features.

But, the American produces only three types of tonneau cover- soft tri-folding, hard tri-folding, soft rolling. On the other hand, the Gator produces almost every type of tonneau covers like Roll up, folding, and retractable. Most of these types have two common variations- soft and hard.

Construction material

Materials used in the production of tonno covers ensures strength and durability. The American tonno covers are well renowned for their built quality. They use Vinyl for finishing, Aluminum frame, and support bows for the main structure.

On the contrary, Gator produces tonneau covers from heavy-duty Vinyl, aluminum framework and bows, and water-resistant foam rubber seals. These materials provide strength to the tonno cover, ensuring long-lasting and satisfying use.

Installation and removal

Both of these manufacturers offer an easy installation that requires no additional drilling. If installation time matters a lot, then American tonno is a bit ahead in the race. You can easily install or remove an American Tonno cover within 5 to 10-minute without using any tools.

On the other hand, most of the Gator tonneau model requires a bit more time to install the cover and make it functioning. The entire installation process can take 20 to 25 minutes using the necessary tools kit. Its quick-release system has made the process of installation and removal easy and user-friendly.


Security is a major concern when you are carrying something into your truck bed. Considering this vital aspect, American tonno producers added a Simple latching system in their truck bed covers. This mechanism offers satisfying protection to the cargo, including easy-to-operate features.

On the contrary, the Gator has a heavy-duty tailgate lock mechanism, along with a tension control design. This security feature has made the cover uncrackable to thrives. Most gator tonneau cover has inbuilt weather protection that means you can use those in rough weather conditions like extremely hot or cold.          


In comparison to the price, American tonneaus are considerably budget-friendly than the Gator tonneau cover. You can expect a price range of $239 to $499 on Amazon, and for a gator tonneau cover, it may be $150 to $1350.

Product Suggestion

To help you choose a perfect tonno, we’ve short-listed some of the best tonneau covers in the market. You can select one from the below list according to your budget and requirements. However, feel free to explore other options too!

Gator Tonneau Cover

Here are two of the best Gator tonneau covers that we like the most-


In conclusion of our American tonneau vs Gator, both of these brands make great tonneau covers. Both are durable, secure, and easy to use. However, if you are looking for less hassle, the American tonneau cover is the way to go. They are more durable, secure, and easy to use. The Gator covers can be more expensive, but they are also more secure. Overall, both are great for your truck, but I think you should go with the American tonno.


5 thoughts on “American Tonneau Vs Gator: Which is Better?”

  1. Pingback: Roll Up Vs. Retractable Tonneau Cover

  2. Pingback: Rolling Vs Folding Tonneau Covers; Which One to Pick for Best Security?

  3. Pingback: Retractable Vs Flip Tonneau Cover: Which is Better?

  4. Pingback: Soft vs Hard Tri-Fold Tonneau Cover: Which is Better? – Truck Bed Facts

  5. Pingback: Polycarbonate Vs Aluminum Tonneau Covers: Which is Better? – Truck Bed Facts

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top